Turkey’s Erdogan faces toughest test yet in landmark election — with high stakes

Turkey is holding both its presidential and parliamentary elections on May 14, and it could scarcely come at a more polarized moment for the country of 85 million.

Just three months after devastating earthquakes there killed more than 50,000 people, the country that boasts NATO’s second-largest military, houses 50 American nuclear warheads, hosts 4 million refugees and has taken up a key role in Russia-Ukraine mediation is staring down an economic crisis years in the making. 

Incumbent President Recep Tayyip Erdogan is in the fight for his political life after two decades in power, having served as Turkey’s prime minister from 2003 to 2014 and president from 2014 onward. He came to prominence as mayor of Istanbul in the 1990s, and was celebrated in the first decade of the new millennium for transforming Turkey’s economy into an emerging market powerhouse. 

But recent years have been far less rosy for the religiously conservative leader, whose own economic policies have triggered a cost-of-living crisis. Tensions between Turkey and the West frequently spike, and international and domestic voices alike sound the alarm that Turkey’s democracy is looking less democratic by the day.

“Under Erdogan’s leadership, Turkey has provided arguably the most vivid template of how a state with plausible, functioning institutions and relatively effective rule of law can be subsumed under the will of first a ruling party and ultimately a single individual,” Hussein Ibish, a senior resident scholar at the Arab Gulf States Institute in Washington, told CNBC.

Turkey’s economy has been in a downward spiral for the past five years, in which time its currency, the lira, lost 77% of its value against the dollar, inflation has ballooned and unemployment has largely worsened. Turkey’s official inflation rate is more than 50%, though economists say in reality it’s higher than 100%.  

“The economy is top of the minds for ordinary Turks and is the driving force behind the weakening support for the government,” Rane’s Bohl said. “If Erdogan and the AKP do lose power, it’ll be almost entirely on economic grounds.”

Erdogan has largely refused to raise interest rates despite ballooning inflation, insisting against all economic orthodoxy that hiking rates worsens inflation, rather than the other way around. This along with expensive central bank interventions propping up the lira, which have led to shrinking foreign currency reserves, sent Turkey’s foreign investors running for the hills over the last few years.    

The current monetary tools Erdogan’s administration has been using to give the economy a semblance of stability are unsustainable, economists warn, and after the election will have to stop — likely leading to severe volatility.

“The currency has to collapse if he [Erdogan] wins, because there will be no confidence and he’s created this artificial scenario that can’t be sustained for a prolonged period of time,” Mike Harris, founder of Cribstone Strategic Macro, boldly predicted in February. 

If the election goes smoothly, “I think we see an uptick in investment into Turkey,” George Dyson, a senior analyst at Control Risks said, adding: “This will be particularly true if the opposition wins — it will show off Turkey’s democratic credentials and ease concerns around the rule of law.”

But a number of challenges loom ahead: a potential fracturing of the opposition alliance, if they win, could “create negative momentum around the economy,” Dyson warned. And worse, if the election result is contested by the loser, with claims of electoral fraud, confidence in the economy will worsen dramatically, he predicted. 

Kilicdaroglu and his opposition coalition propose a very different economic path forward if they win. 

“Importantly for investors, the opposition wants to return to an orthodox monetary system vs. the incumbent administration’s heterodox policymaking,” Goldman Sachs analysts wrote in a research note Thursday. 

Still, in either case “one should not expect miracles overnight as efforts to tame inflation with higher rates would likely cause currency shocks in the near-term,” warned Hakan Akbas, managing director of consulting firm Strategic Advisory Services, based between Istanbul and Washington. “However,” he added, “a new political leadership with a credible, competent economy team will have more support and patience from investors.”

“Turkey is a member of the Western alliance and NATO and Putin also knows this well,” Kilicdaroglu told the Wall Street Journal in an interview this week. “Turkey must comply with decisions taken by NATO.”

Kilicdaroglu also “wants to prioritize close economic relations with Europe in particular, while the incumbent administration’s current non-aligned policy stance would likely continue,” Goldman Sachs analysts wrote in their note.

Still, Turkey’s spearheading of negotiations for the U.N.-brokered Black Sea grain deal, which has helped ensure vital Ukrainian food exports reach countries that need them, is likely to continue regardless of who takes power. Country analysts also believe that if Erdogan wins, he will ultimately acquiesce to Sweden’s NATO membership, and will continue to try to mediate between Ukraine and Russia.

But the power of nationalism and Erdogan’s popularity in Turkey means that “even if he loses, his national presence and policy influence will not have vanished,” Ibish said.

“If Erdogan wins, of course, we can expect more of the same: a continuation on uneasy terms of the Turkish membership in NATO and relations with European and other Western states. But it’s not going to be pretty.”