The long-standing theory that John Wayne’s Ethan is really Debbie’s father in The Searchers completely changed how I saw the classic Western. Of all the John Wayne/John Ford collaborations, The Searchers is commonly regarded as the best. More than that, it’s recognized as arguably the greatest Western ever made, and The Searchers was one of Wayne’s favorite movies of his own. The setup is simple; after his family is slaughtered during a Comanche raid and his niece Debbie is kidnapped, a bitter Civil War vet sets out on a years-long odyssey to find her.
The story is straightforward, but The Searchers is rich in subtext and meaning, with Wayne’s Ethan Edwards being one of his darkest roles. Ethan is a violent, racist figure, and it’s heavily implied he would rather kill Debbie due to her spending so much time with the Comanche than rescue her. There’s also a very convincing theory that Ethan is Debbie’s father, and the result of an affair he had with her mother before he left for the Civil War.
I Can’t Watch John Wayne’s The Searchers Now Without Buying Into The “Ethan Is Debbie’s Father” Theory
This Searchers theory makes too much sense
I’d seen The Searchers a few times before I’d heard of this Ethan/Debbie theory and found it to be a fantastic, if surprisingly dark, adventure. I was pretty young the first time I saw Ford’s magnum opus, so there were certain elements I didn’t pick up on. This includes the unspoken connection between Ethan and his brother’s wife, Martha (Dorothy Jordan), with the two being unusually tender toward one another. The next time I saw the film with the father theory, it opened up the story in a brand new way.
Most fan theories I tend to dismiss – such as the “James Bond is a codename” idea – since they’re usually easily dismissed by watching the movies themselves. It’s also doubtful the filmmakers involved intended such readings when they made the movies. In the case of The Searchers, I can easily see Ford underselling the idea that Ethan is Debbie’s father and leaving it to viewers to figure out. The whole concept just works; it explains the weird bond between Ethan and Martha, and why he would push himself to obsessive lengths to save her daughter.
A modern film would save this shock reveal for the third act, but The Searchers leaves it as another, unspoken layer..
It also makes sense that this would go unspoken, because who would talk about it? Martha and her husband Aaron are killed early in the story, and while Ethan is the only one who knows the truth, there’s no reason for him to confess it. A modern film would save this shock reveal for the third act – in fact, The Searchers sci-fi/horror remake Priest does exactly that – but The Searchers leaves it as another, unspoken layer of the story. This theory also makes the Western even more tragic and melancholy.
How The Searchers Backs Up The Debbie Fan Theory
Ethan and Martha sure seem close
Once this theory made me take a closer look at The Searchers, I couldn’t stop seeing the evidence to back it up. Most of this comes from the famous opening, where Ethan returns home after years away. Martha is VERY happy to see him, while Aaron is colder and more restrained. Ethan is also particularly friendly to his niece Debbie, gifting her one of his medals; it should be noted that Debbie is eight years old, while Ethan left to fight in the Civil War eight years prior.
It’s the relationship between Ethan and Martha that powers a lot of this theory. They don’t say much to each other, but there are a lot of charged glances, and the last time Ethan sees her is when he heads off to investigate the theft of some cattle; this is later revealed to be a ploy to lure the men away from their ranches. In this scene, Martha gives Ethan’s coat a loving glance before handing it to him.
Related
John Wayne was once very eager to work with Cilnt Eastwood, only for the younger star to reject one of Wayne’s best Westerns from 1969.
They share a tender embrace while Rev. Capt. Johnson (played by Ford regular Ward Bond) pretends not to notice. If Johnson is aware of some past romantic connection between them, that almost certainly means that Aaron is aware too. Tellingly, when Ethan and the other men later return to the homestead to find it raided, the only name he shouts for is “Martha!” The devastation he feels at finding her (unseen) body is what partly fuels his rage for the rest of The Searchers.
The Searchers co-star Jeffrey Hunter is best known for playing Captain Pike in Star Trek: The Original Series.
Again, part of what’s great is that none of this is communicated through dialogue. The Searchers implies so much about Martha and Ethan’s relationship (and, in turn, Ethan’s connection to Debbie) entirely through visuals and body language. I didn’t pick up on it the first time, but it’s impossible to overlook now.
This Searchers Theory Makes The Movie A Richer Experience For Me
I notice something new about The Searchers each time I see it
Some of the best movies reward multiple rewatches, where viewers notice details about the story, characters or world they missed the first time out. The Ethan/Debbie theory not only makes The Searchers a richer text, it made me examine it in a new light. The Searchers ending, for instance, is even more haunting now. I had always read that Ethan left his family after saving Debbie because he knew he had been so poisoned by violence and hate that he could never return home.
That reading is still there, but it’s given extra poignancy if Ethan is Debbie’s dad. This means that throughout the film, Ethan would have been shouldering the guilt of having fathered a child with his brother’s wife, and vowing to never reveal the truth to her. Ethan no doubt felt it was his duty to Martha to save their child, no matter what – even if, in his mind, that meant killing Debbie if he felt she had converted to the Comanche way of life.
… wandering the desert also mirrors one of The Searchers’ darkest moments, where Ethan shoots the eyes out of a Comanche corpse.
In The Searchers‘ closing scenes, Ethan’s love for his daughter means he can’t bring himself to do that. This underlying subplot adds another emotional engine to the John Wayne Western. Turning his back on his family and wandering the desert also mirrors one of the movie’s darkest moments, where Ethan shoots the eyes out of a Comanche corpse. Ethan states that, according to Native American customs, a body without eyes condemns the man’s spirit to wander the desert for eternity. In The Searcher’s final shot, that’s basically the fate that befalls Ethan for his own misdeeds.
This story originally appeared on Screenrant
