Wednesday, September 17, 2025

 
HomeOPINIONWith twisted ruling tossing Luigi Mangione terror charges, judge endorses political violence

With twisted ruling tossing Luigi Mangione terror charges, judge endorses political violence


Plainly believing that America isn’t seeing enough political violence, Justice Gregory Carro just tossed the terrorism charges in Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg’s murder case against Luigi Mangione.

The district attorney, Carro ruled, hadn’t proved that Mangione “acted with terroristic intent” . . . simply because the judge reads Luigi’s writings as only indicating a desire “to draw attention to what he perceived as the greed of the insurance industry.”

For starters: The DA’s job is to convince the jury, not the judge, of Mangione’s motives; Carro essentially prejudged evidence and arguments the prosecution would produce at trial, and with a truly bizarre reading of the law.

Luigi Mangione still faces federal charges in the case. AP

The relevant statues defines terrorism as “an act intended to intimidate or coerce a civilian population, influence government policy, or affect government conduct.”

The premeditated and calculated execution of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson plainly aimed to strike terror and fear among (that is, intimidate) other health insurers — and insurers are, in fact, civilians

And Mangione absolutely aimed to “influence government policy”: that’s the point of “drawing attention” to “greed.”

Horribly, Carro’s lawless ruling won cheers from the leftists gathered outside the court, who believe that their gripes about the health-care system justify Thompson’s murder.


Protestors holding signs that say "Free Luigi!" outside a courthouse.
Outside of Luigi Mangione’s criminal hearing where chants of Free Luigi! were shouted by supporters across the street from the courthouse. Robert Miller

That is, Carro won the approval of ghouls who support terrorism in the name of this cause.

His ruling is so bizarre that you have to wonder if he does, too.



This story originally appeared on NYPost

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Recent Comments