Monday, November 16, 2026

 
HomeMOVIES8 Actors Who Should Replace Robert Pattinson as Batman Now That He’s...

8 Actors Who Should Replace Robert Pattinson as Batman Now That He’s James Bond



Now that Robert Pattinson is officially cast as James Bond in Amazon MGM’s upcoming reboot, there are plenty of questions about what lies ahead for Batman.

Given the demanding schedule of playing 007, it seems unlikely that Pattinson will continue as The Dark Knight after the release of The Batman: Part II. This, coupled with the change in leadership at DC Studios, suggests Warner Bros. and their new owners, Skydance, will be searching for a new Batman.

Thankfully, audiences have gotten used to the idea of a new Batman. Several actors ranging from Michael Keaton to George Clooney and Ben Affleck have taken on the role of the Caped Crusader.

Robert Pattinson was never going to be the last Batman, and the character will ultimately be recast, particularly if there are plans for Batman to join the Justice League. Whether it’s a recasting of Robert Pattinson, the DCU Batman that could potentially continue after Man of Tomorrow, or a full-on DC reboot, these are actors who would step into the role perfectly.

Paul Mescal

If Warner Bros. wanted to continue Matt Reeves’ The Batman universe but needed to recast Pattinson’s specific take on Bruce Wayne, Paul Mescal would be an ideal replacement.

After his breakout performance in 2023’s Aftersun, which earned him a Best Actor Academy Award nomination, Mescal has become one of today’s most acclaimed actors. He has tackled projects ranging from the Oscar-nominated Hamnet to the action legacy sequel Gladiator II. Next, he will step into the iconic role of Paul McCartney in the four-part Beatles biopic set for release in 2028.

At 30, Mescal is the youngest actor on this list. However, given that The Batman and The Batman — Part II are supposed to focus on a younger incarnation of The Dark Knight that Pattinson has already started aging out of, Mescal could keep the series going. Mescal is a respected enough actor that the prospect of him taking over for Robert Pattinson won’t be received as poorly as discarding the entire saga would be.

Jensen Ackles

Ever since Supernatural, Jensen Ackles has been a favorite suggestion to play Batman in some version of the DC Universe, whether film or television.

The actor has already dabbled in the DC Multiverse. He played an original character, Jason Teague, on Smallville and voiced both Jason Todd/The Red Hood in Batman: Under the Red Hood and Bruce Wayne/Batman in the Tomorrowverse continuity. He could make the leap from voicing the character to playing him in live-action.

Ackles would be an older, more seasoned Batman. In fact, he’s the type of Batman one could imagine, having trained multiple Robins and being the parent of a 13-year-old son like Damian Wayne.

Although it’s unclear if DC Studios’ new president, Jeremy Latcham, will stick to Gunn’s initial Brave and the Bold plans for Batman, Ackles would fit that vision very well. The potential issue is his commitment to another superhero property, as he is set to reprise his role as Soldier Boy in The Boys‘ prequel spin-off, Vought Rising.

Alan Ritchson

Before stepping down as the co-chairman of DC Studios, Peter Safran hinted that Alan Ritchson was in talks for a DCU role. It’s unclear if that is still the case, but given Reacher‘s popularity, Skydance will likely have Ritchson on their radar. Ritchson himself is no stranger to the DC Universe, having already played Aquaman on Smallville and Hawk on Titans.

Casting Ritchson would signal a different vision for Batman. Ritchson’s massive physique makes him an ideal pick for a Batman who feels like a comic-book character brought to life. If Warner Bros. and DC Studios took a gamble and based their upcoming film on the recently acclaimed Absolute Batman run, Ritchson would be the ideal choice to play a hulking version of the Caped Crusader.

Ethan Peck

Ethan Peck is best known to audiences for playing Spock in Star Trek: Strange New Worlds. The grandson of the legendary Gregory Peck has already shown an ability to play the detached, over-analytical member of an ensemble, which is a role Batman typically occupies in the DC Universe.

With Star Trek: Strange New Worlds having finished filming and Season 5 set to air in 2027, the actor would have room in his schedule to take on a multi-year commitment like Batman.

While Peck isn’t a household name, being cast as Batman could showcase his talents to a wider audience and could make him a star, which is what happened when David Corenswet played Superman. One thing that Peck has in his favor is the intensity of his eyes.

Given that Batman needs to convey a lot underneath a cowl, Peck’s piercing eyes paired with his strong jawline could be like the perfect marriage of Pattinson’s and Affleck’s Batman portrayals.

Brandon Sklenar

Brandon Sklenar campaigned hard to play Batman in the DCU when James Gunn was in charge of the shared universe. The 1923 actor told MovieWeb in 2025:

“I’d make it my own for sure — like, more true to the comic. I love Christian [Bale’s] version, probably my favorite version of Batman. But I’d want him to see, like, lean more into Bruce Wayne being Bruce Wayne, how he is in the comics, and then make Batman as dark as possible.”

Sklenar is a fairly unknown actor, and some might recognize him from It Ends with Us or The Housemaid. This goes against the conventions of most Batman casting. James Gunn noted in his podcast about The Suicide Squad that Batman is typically cast “as a movie star.” However, that makes Sklenar a prime pick for Batman, since audiences would associate him with Batman more than other roles.

Tom Bateman

Tom Bateman as Batman. It’s right there in the name (minus the e). In all seriousness, Bateman would be a fantastic choice to take on Batman either as a replacement for Robert Pattinson or as part of a shared universe. With his background studying at the London Academy of Music and Dramatic Arts, the actor has appeared in a variety of films ranging from the murder mystery Murder on the Orient Express to the period piece drama Hedda.

However, his recent turn in the romantic comedy, The Love Hypothesis, makes the best argument for him as Batman. Bateman’s depiction of a cold, emotionally distant genius who secretly hides a caring heart under an intense presence naturally lends itself to this character. Thanks to his romantic leading-man looks paired with a natural charm that can easily become brooding intensity, Bateman could be the new lead that the DC Universe desperately needs.

Jonathan Bailey

Jonathan Bailey is another strong contender to take on the cape and cowl for the DC Universe. Being voted People’s Sexiest Man Alive in 2025 and receiving praise for performances in Bridgerton and Wicked certainly suits the billionaire persona of Bruce Wayne. Bailey’s impressive turn in the Audible production of Dracula showcased a darker side that would serve Batman well.

Thanks to Bailey’s report with David Corenswet in Variety’s Actor on Actor’s appearance, he should be a top pick to co-lead the Justice League alongside Corenswet’s Superman. Bailey expressed interest in playing Batman during an appearance on The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, although that was during James Gunn’s tenure. However, Warner Bros. and DC Studios would be foolish to overlook Bailey as the next Batman.

Josh O’Connor

Josh O’Connor might have lost the role of James Bond to Robert Pattinson, but that might be for the best. The actor might be the perfect person to take over Batman. From playing a tortured but good-hearted man of faith in Knives Out: Wake Up Dead Man to a sleazy but charming romantic lead in Challengers to an action hero in Disclosure Day, O’Connor has more than proven that he’s qualified to play Batman.

If Corenswet continues to play Superman and the rumor is true that Adria Arjona is playing Wonder Woman in Man of Tomorrow, O’Connor is the most exciting pick to play Batman. That DC Trinity of rising talent could carry the franchise for over a decade.

He would follow the unconventional casting mold of Pattinson, Michael Keaton, and Christian Bale. O’Connor is one of the best actors working today, and James Bond’s lost potential could be DC’s future.



This story originally appeared on Movieweb

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Recent Comments