Thursday, November 19, 2026

 
HomeOPINIONThe filibuster hangs by a thread — and the Founders' system may...

The filibuster hangs by a thread — and the Founders’ system may shatter

And so it begins. 

About to take control of the US Senate with a robust 56 seats, Democrats are now debating whether to eliminate the filibuster — and change the nature of the institution forever. 

Every Senate majority is irked by the filibuster and President Donald Trump has always hated it, but it’s an essential element of our system of government.

Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen, who is challenging Chuck Schumer for majority leader from the left, calls the filibuster “anti-democratic,” and says that “it’s not in our Constitution.”

He claims that “it was put in there by senators to enhance their power over the power of the people.”

It’s apparently too much to ask someone who has been a senator since 2017 to actually know something about the chamber of Congress that he seeks to lead. 

The Constitution is designed to give the states a significant role in the political system, and to make large-scale changes at the federal level difficult to enact.

The United States Senate serves both these purposes, through the equal representation that it gives states — both large and small — and its balky, highly deliberative nature.

If Van Hollen thinks the filibuster is anti-democratic, just wait until he finds out that originally senators weren’t elected, but selected by state legislatures (the 17th Amendment providing for direct election wasn’t ratified until 1913).

Van Hollen’s view of the filibuster as something artificially created at some point to give senators more power is also false.

Endless talk has been a tactic in the Senate going back to the very beginning.

One Pennsylvania senator complained in 1789 that the “design of the Virginians . . . was to talk away the time, so that we could not get the bill passed.” 

The word “filibuster” was coined by the 1850s.

It was cloture — or a mechanism to end debate — that was the innovation, with senators agitating for it beginning around the 1840s.

The Senate adopted a cloture provision in 1917, allowing a two-thirds majority to cut off debate.

In 1975, the threshold for cloture was reduced to three-fifths, or today’s magic number of 60. 

The filibuster has been eroded over the years, but the procedure has been essentially preserved — and it’s a very good thing. 

It forces bipartisan compromise, and is a bar to momentous, centralizing changes enacted by temporary, inflamed congressional majorities.

That’s exactly why the left hates it. 

Not long ago, it was a matter of consensus that the filibuster was part and parcel of the Senate and a useful obstacle to heedlessly partisan legislation.

Dick Durbin, among other influential Democrats, warned in 2018 that nuking the filibuster “would be the end of the Senate as it was originally devised.”

The authors of the anti-Trump book “How Democracies Die” thought that “the elimination of the filibuster and other rules that protect Senate minorities” would constitute a “nightmare scenario” for our democracy.

Obviously, a lot of Democrats only favored the filibuster so long as Trump was president — and as soon as Biden won in 2020, only Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema stood in the way of its destruction. 

Now, the filibuster is an obstacle to getting bills to Trump’s desk for big veto fights, and, looking ahead, to massive, destabilizing changes to our constitutional order should Democrats win unified control of Washington in 2028.

There’s no way that Democrats are going to succeed in packing the Supreme Court or adding Washington, DC, and Puerto Rico as new Democratic states if they need 60 votes in the Senate. 

That makes the filibuster the canary in the coal mine for our system of government.

If the filibuster dies, it clears the path for potentially sweeping changes from which American government as we know it may never recover.

In other words, just the sort of constitutional recklessness and self-destructive acts the Founders wanted the United States Senate, by its very nature, to prevent.

X: @RichLowry



This story originally appeared on NYPost

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Recent Comments