Saturday, November 21, 2026

 
HomeOPINIONNutty NYC pols want to protect lobster from being boiled — but...

Nutty NYC pols want to protect lobster from being boiled — but what the rights of about people?

Boiling live lobsters is cruel — never mind that the primitive creatures have no brains and can’t complain on TikTok or mount a street protest.

But I suggest, in the spirit of sparing the poor crustaceans from  suffering, that City Council members  Oswald Feliz of the Bronx and Harvey Epstein of Manhattan take their places in the pot next time one becomes available.

The chuckleheads are behind the new bill to penalize any food-service establishment  that permits “the placement of a live crustacean into boiling liquid for the purpose of cooking or preparing such crustacean for human consumption.”

City Council members are behind a bill to penalize any food-service establishment that permits “the placement of a live crustacean into boiling liquid for the purpose of cooking or preparing such crustacean for human consumption.” Bart – stock.adobe.com

Will they  next  go after Raid Ant & Roach Killer to spare insects from a  twitching, no doubt painful, demise?

Neither Council member  seems to care that a ban on boiling lobsters alive would put entire restaurants like Red Hook Lobster Pound out of business and cripple scores of others. Heck, they can always switch to selling tofu!

The lobster lunacy isn’t a “Real Time With Bill Maher” joke but an actual attempt to “amend the administrative code of New York City” — to protect  any “aquatic invertebrate belonging to the subphylum Crustacea, including, but not limited to, a lobster or crab intended for human consumption,” from a fast boil.

Placing the  comfort of hard-shell organisms over the nutritional needs and pleasure of human beings has long been a  priority of animal-welfare  scolds — like their stalled campaign to ban foie gras sales (the delicacy remains available as court challenges continue).

Royal eggs Benedict with caviar and lobster is served at Delmonico’s in New York. Stefano Giovannini

The situation would be comical if characters like Felix and Epstein  didn’t have backing  from the body’s increasingly lefty-looney majority.

As The Post reported in August, doozies introduced by various members include  giving workers “sick days” for taking care of ailing pets; banning citizens from keeping elephants, which throw tantrums on so  many city blocks; and requiring government agencies to buy only free-range eggs (never mind that chickens prefer to stay in their coops over wandering in the three-foot-long enclosures that define “free range”).

Even by those wacky standards, the campaign to fine  restaurants for boiling lobsters — a globally common cooking technique essential to preserving their freshness and flavor — is in a cockamamie category of its own.

New York City Council member Oswald Feliz at a press conference on e-bike batteries at New York City Hall in New York on March 2, 2023. JOHN NACION/Shutterstock
New York City Council member Harvey Epstein speaks at the Patients Before Politics: Protect Trans Lives rally in Washington Square Park on May 16, 2026. Robert Miller for NY Post

Feliz,  who chairs the Council’s Committee on Public Safety, apparently values crustacean safety over that of humans in his 15th  district, home to  central Bronx neighborhoods with some of  the city’s highest violent-crime rates, including homicide.

Epstein’s 2nd District covers Greenwich Village and other downtown nabes. A prime mover behind the just-signed ban on carriage horses, his sympathies lie with a few noisy animal-rights zealots over  the plight of human coach drivers  who will lose their livelihoods — and a century-old institution that’s synonymous with Central Park and what  it represents to New York City.

Citing a made-up reign of horse-drawn terror, Epstein and fellow Council member Christopher Marte penned a July  op-ed article for City & State claiming  a scourge of “dangerous incidents” prior to a single tragic, accidental death in June.

Alas, City & State subsequently determined the story was “partially written with the use of generative artificial intelligence, which violates our guidelines.”

But artificial intelligence has nothing on real-world stupidity.

Heat up the pots and boil away!



This story originally appeared on NYPost

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Recent Comments