Russia faces tough choice over supporting Israel or Hamas-funder Iran

The outbreak of bloodshed, violence and outright war between Israel and Hamas has put Russia in an awkward position, with Moscow traditionally treading a fine diplomatic line between Israel and its allies in the Middle East.

Russia’s position on the current conflict in Israel is likely to be nuanced and a challenge for Moscow to navigate given its conflicting ties in the region, analysts say.

Russia has enjoyed warm and constructive relations with Israel in recent years. But since its invasion of Ukraine last year, Moscow has greatly increased its military ties to Iran, a sworn enemy of Israel and a state known to have provided financial and material support to the Palestinian militant group Hamas, which launched an unprecedented attack on Israel last weekend.

“Russia’s stance on the conflict is complex,” Tatiana Stanovaya, senior fellow at the Carnegie Russia Eurasia Center and the founder of analysis firm R.Politik, said in an analysis note Monday.

“On the one hand, Moscow might draw on its history of intra-Palestinian mediation and its ties with Hamas to gain a foothold in any peace process. It also sees the importance of its growing relationships with Iran and Arab states,” she noted.

“On the other hand, despite recent tensions, Russia’s relationship with Israel remains strong and pragmatic, hallmarked by open lines of communication, a degree of practical coordination in Syria and shared views on the historical significance of the Second World War.”

“The fact that Israel has not imposed Western anti-Russian sanctions is also notable,” Stanovaya said.

Under President Vladimir Putin’s efforts to expand Russia’s influence and presence in the Middle East, Moscow has propped up Bashar Assad’s regime in Syria (a country that, like Iran, does not recognize Israel as a legitimate state) and in return has a military presence in the country, and has looked to deepen ties — or extend its reach, depending on how you look at it — with Lebanon, Egypt and Iraq.

Russia is particularly close to Iran, and Western intelligence and evidence suggests Tehran has provided Moscow with military weaponry, predominantly drones, artillery and tank rounds, for use in its war against Ukraine.

Iran has regularly denied supplying weaponry to Moscow but admitted to selling drones, saying it had done so months before the Feb. 2022 invasion of Ukraine.

Putin has enjoyed cordial relations with his Israeli counterpart, Benjamin Netanyahu, who has leveraged Russia’s influence over Syria to secure Israel’s northern border.

But the war in Ukraine has put Israel in an uncomfortable position, with its Western allies, and particularly the U.S., reportedly pressuring Netanyahu to distance himself from Putin and to back Ukraine instead.

Despite calls for a “diplomatic solution” to end the conflict, Israel has so far resisted sending weapons to Ukraine, or to whole-heartedly endorse and impose sanctions on Russia for its invasion.

Putin is holding talks with Iraqi Prime Minister Mohammed Shia’ Al Sudani in the Kremlin Tuesday and said turmoil in the Middle East would be on the agenda. Yet Russia’s initial response to the outbreak of violence in Israel at the weekend was muted, with its foreign ministry issuing a statement calling for a cease-fire.

The foreign ministry also used the opportunity to criticize the West’s poor record on brokering a peace deal between Israel and Palestinian territories and said it had blocked efforts by international mediators, namely Russia, to find a long-lasting peace deal between Israeli and Palestinian authorities.

The Kremlin said Monday that it was “extremely concerned” by the situation but, tellingly, said Putin had no plans, as yet, to contact either Israeli or Palestinian officials to discuss the security crisis.

It didn’t go un-noticed that an emergency meeting of the U.N. Security Council members did not reach a consensus on condemning the attack and Russia and China did not openly condemn the violence meted out by Hamas but alluded to Israel’s shortfalls and “unresolved issues” that they said had led to the current crisis.

As a result of Russia’s lukewarm support, Ian Bremmer, founder and president of Eurasia Group, believed the “Russia-Israel relationship, which had been reasonably balanced, will face a decisive break on the back of the Hamas attacks.”

For its part, Iran denied any involvement in Hamas’ surprise offensive against Israel that began on Saturday morning, although it did congratulate the militant group for what it described as its “anti-Zionist resistance” across the region.

Meanwhile, U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken said Sunday on CNN’s “State of the Union” that the U.S. had “not yet seen evidence that Iran directed or was behind this particular attack, but there is certainly a long relationship.”

Russia is certainly likely to try to use the eruption of violence in Israel to distract from its operations in Ukraine, analysts at the Institute for the Study of War (ISW) noted in analysis on Saturday.

Highlighting that the Kremlin had already amplified several information operations after Hamas’ attacks in Israel on Saturday — primarily blaming the West for neglecting conflicts in the Middle East in favor of supporting Ukraine — the ISW said Russia was claiming the international community will cease to pay attention to Ukraine.

Deputy Chairman of the Russian Security Council, Dmitry Medvedev, claimed on X that the U.S. and its allies should have been “busy with” working on a “Palestinian-Israeli settlement” rather than “interfering” with Russia and providing Ukraine with military aid.

Meanwhile, prominent Russian propagandist Sergei Mardan stated on Telegram that Russia would benefit from the conflict in Israel as the world “will take its mind off Ukraine for a while and get busy once again putting out the eternal fire in the Middle East.”