While it’s hard to believe that Justified premiered on FX 15 years ago, the breathtaking opening scene still holds up incredibly well in 2025. The genre-bending neo-western TV series from creator Graham Yost adapts the brilliant writing of Elmore Leonard, whose source novella Fire in the Hole serves as the blueprint for the series and the name of the inaugural episode.
Between the exquisite writing and deft direction by journeyman Michael Dinner, it’s hard for any TV show to top the opening moments of Justified‘s first episode. As such, it’s no real surprise that Dinner helmed and produced the 2023 follow-up series, Justified: City Primeval, which finds Raylan Givens (Timothy Olyphant) solving crimes in Detroit. With both series available on Hulu, analyzing Justified‘s jaw-dropping opening scene during its 15th anniversary will crystallize what made the crime show so entertaining and push the neo-western genre to new frontiers.
‘Justified’s Premise, Explained
Based on venerated crime novelist Elmore Leonard’s Fire in the Hole, Justified immediately introduces Raylan Givens (Olyphant), a throwback lawman to classic Western movie and TV show antiheroes who take no nonsense and don’t easily suffer fools. Set in Appalachia near Kentucky, Raylan is a U.S. Marshal adhering to an old-school way of handling criminals and investigating crimes, with his approach to law enforcement often stuck in the past.
Ripped out of the Old West and dropped into modern times, Raylan embodies a cowboy machismo that rubs many the wrong way on both sides of the law. His rebellious insubordination often lands him in trouble with Chief Deputy Art Mullen (Nick Searcy). Raylan also steps on the toes of his ex-wife, Winona Hawkins (Natalie Zea), and fellow U.S. Marshals, including Tim Gutterson (Jacob Pitts), and Rachel Brooks (Erica Tazel).
While Raylan tracks down several criminals throughout Justified‘s 78-episode run, his primary antagonists remain Boyd Crowder (Walton Goggins) and his wife, Ava Crowder (Joelle Carter), who emerge as Harlan County, Kentucky’s most powerful crime syndicate. Apart from the Appalachian environment that serves as a character in the story, Justified was extolled for its top-notch writing, skillful direction, and Olyphant’s gruff, morally ambiguous Raylan; all of which are on glorious display in the opening scene of Episode 1.
‘Justified’s Tone-Setting Opening Scene
Justified begins with a low angle on a man’s back surrounded by a blue sky. Wearing a tan suit and Stetson cowboy hat, the man takes a few steps forward, with the camera bending down to reveal palm trees and a vibrant poolside party. Cuban jazz begins playing in the background. The camera reverses to show the man’s face as he stands against prominent palm fronds. This is Raylan Givens. The shot holds on Raylan’s face for a few beats as he quizzically looks for someone in the crowd.
As the action tracks Raylan past the pool down a row of deckchairs, a title card reads: Miami, Florida. Suddenly, the throng of partygoers is gone, and Raylan meets a lone man at a swanky seaside dining table overlooking the water. The man is a powerful mobster named Thomas Buckley (Peter Greene). In a classic Western duel set in a much different environment, Raylan reminds Thomas that he gave him 24 hours to flee town and only has two minutes left to depart for the airport.
Thomas defiantly refuses to leave, claiming he’s loved this spot in Miami his whole life. Thomas extends hospitality by asking Raylan to share a meal with him, telling him the crab cakes are better than the ones they’ve had in the past. This establishes that Raylan and Thomas have a long history. Yet, in a pitch-perfect characterization, Raylan affably disagrees with Thomas’ culinary take, saying he enjoyed a pork dish during their time together in Mexico or Puerto Rico. Then he gives Thomas one minute to leave.
Related
Every Western Movie and TV Show Starring Timothy Olyphant, Ranked
With quite a few roles in westerns, Timothy Olyphant should be celebrated as one of the genre’s greatest actors.
From the jump, Raylan is agreeably disagreeable, his primary trait. Thomas laughs off the warning about the 24-hour rule, prompting Raylan to ask Thomas if he told his friends “About the man you killed, the way you did it?” Thomas continues to call Raylan’s bluff, suggesting he should have killed Raylan instead. Thomas goads Raylan, asking, “You’re going to shoot an unarmed man?“
In classic Western fashion, the camera cuts between both men in a close-up. Tense music grows louder. “20 seconds,” says Raylan, in what has become a ticking clock scenario chock-full of tension and suspense. A wide angle shows the men at opposite ends of the table with the Atlantic Ocean and the beach below. “10,” Raylan unflappably utters.
The music swells up. More intense leering ensues. Suddenly, Thomas pulls a handgun from his right side and is instantly blasted with three gunshots by Raylan, who pulls a gun from his hip and shoots Thomas three times in the chest through his cocktail glass. Fresh blood speckles his seafood linguine. The partygoers express horror in the background as Thomas drops his gun and slinks dead in his chair. The scene ends with the camera on Raylan’s grizzled face, no worse for wear.
How ‘Justified’s Opening Redefines Western Tropes
Throughout Justified‘s tour-de-force opener, the series reworks the classic Western movie tropes and flips them on their head. It begins with the presence of palm trees, which stand in for cacti and call to mind the classic desert setting most Westerns occur in. Later, when the wide shot reveals a sandy beach below, more visual links to the classic Western setting reinforce the theme.
Another example of how Justified‘s opener redefines the Western genre relates to the Atlantic Ocean. During much of the scene, the tableside showdown between Raylan and Thomas prominently features the blue water and horizon behind their heads. Visually, the ocean represents an uncharted frontier. By setting this scene on the coast’s edge, it is subtly conveyed that Raylan will push his law enforcement methods as far as possible.
The setting and how its iconography is framed in the scene are a nuanced way of communicating that Raylan is elevating the classic Western tropes and tenets to new territorial heights. The music also adds a much more vibrant flair than dusty old Western scores, another way of showing how Justified advances the age-old genre formula. The show may begin in the Southeast, but as Raylan advances, he will head to Appalachia as the show leans more into its themes of westward expansion.
Related
10 Underrated Westerns to Watch on Netflix Right Now, Ranked
Capturing the grit and grandeur of the Old West and streaming right now.
As for Raylan’s clean get-up, notice how he wears tan, not black, not white, but somewhere in between. It’s an apt metaphor for his moral standing and approach to law enforcement. While adorning Raylan in gray would have been too on-the-nose, draping him in tan during his introduction subconsciously conveys that he is neither a hero nor villain, but an antiheroic go-between that informs his actions.
Then there’s the scintillating showdown itself. A refreshing riff on a well-worn Western movie trope — the duel — writer Graham Yost and director Michael Dinner beautifully sidestep conventions. Most gunfights occur at a distance, with the gunners on their feet, often agreeing to pull the trigger simultaneously. Here, Raylan and Thomas are sitting mere feet from each other, with the latter claiming he’s unarmed. Therefore, the sudden bullet explosion is far less telegraphed than a traditional Western movie duel, and much more thrilling and unpredictable.
Beyond the character establishment and neo-western tenets, the outstanding performances by Olyphant and Greene are what make Justified‘s opening scene so iconic. Greene has been stealing crime movie scenes since Pulp Fiction and The Usual Suspects, reminding viewers of his smoldering onscreen intensity. Olyphant, meanwhile, plays the scene with steely charisma that instantly lets viewers know where he stands on the moral spectrum of the law. Justified is available to stream on Hulu.
This story originally appeared on Movieweb
