The One Ring of Sauron is among the most infamous and powerful magical items in fantasy literature, and there are seldom few in J.R.R. Tolkien’s expansive Lord of the Rings universe who are able to bear it without quickly succumbing to its corruption. As the physical anchor for all of Sauron’s evil, malice, and desire to dominate all life, the One Ring is capable of nudging events towards its own recovery when it is not in Sauron’s hands. While it doesn’t have a literal mind of its own, as an imprint of Sauron’s own malevolent spirit, it manipulates its bearers via psychological torment, making it feel unbearably heavy, producing torturous visions, and corrupting their minds with doubt, paranoia, guilt, and fear.
Of the few creatures that have managed to bear its unfathomable evil, only a few have resist it to any degree. The physical and spiritual makeup of the bearer plays a significant role, although their lust for power (or lack thereof) and the manner in which they came to acquire it also play a role. In examining the eight different bearers of the One Ring, we looked at all Lord of the Rings media, from Tolkien’s original novels and appendices to the Peter Jackson trilogies and Rings of Power TV series.
Honorable Mention
Gandalf: While Gandalf never actually wore the ring or took it on as his burden, he did technically handle the Ring before and after throwing it in the fire at Bag End as he introduced its dark history to Frodo. In Peter Jackson’s movies, he goes out of his way not to handle it directly, a conscious choice meant to further imply just how damaging it could be in the hands of one of Middle-earth’s wizards. Gandalf deserves credit for resisting it when he could have taken it at any time, but he does not technically count as a ring-bearer.
8
Sauron
The Dark Lord is one with the Ring.
Speaking of technicalities, Sauron is technically the first true ring-bearer as its creator. Once he pours his evil spirit into the One Ring during the crafting process, he is entirely bound to it. His power and will to dominate are tied to the Ring, a process he executed in order to exert even more control over those who wore the other rings, and to amplify his ability to inflict his will on others. Such a tethering, of course, led to the fatal weakness that he could be destroyed if the Ring is destroyed, but that was a calculated (and arrogant) risk taken by Sauron in his quest to dominate all life.
7
Déagol
The Hobbit-like creature held the Ring for only a few minutes.
Described as one of the “river folk” in Peter Jackson’s trilogy, Sméagol and his companion Déagol are canonically Stoors, one of the Hobbit-like breeds of Middle-earth (their original tribe is encountered by Nori of the Harfoots in Rings of Power). Despite being a halfling with no designs on power, Deagol is immediately transfixed by the One Ring he finds at the bottom of the Anduin River. We don’t get to find out just how resistant he might have been to its evil, as he is murdered by Smeagol moments after his companion sees it.
6
Sméagol/Gollum
The One Ring poisoned Gollum for almost 500 years before he lost it.


The creature that eventually evolved into the wretch referred to as Gollum was immediately captivated by the One Ring just as his companion was, the only difference being that in their deadly struggle for it, Sméagol emerged victorious. He showed virtually no ability to resist the Ring because of his personality before he had it, which was that of a sneak and a thief. The Ring amplified those traits, and his early use of it for further thievery and misdeeds drove him even deeper into its corruption. He also murdered someone to obtain it, marking him as an already corrupted soul that stood absolutely no chance of resisting its evil.
5
Isildur
The king who destroyed Sauron’s mortal form only held the Ring for two years.
The High King of Gondor was fortunate to destroy Sauron’s mortal form when he cut the Ring from Sauron’s hand on the slopes of Mount Doom, and was granted a chance to destroy it forever shortly thereafter. However, as a mortal man driven by grief over his father and brother’s deaths and kingly pride, Isildur’s soul was easily corrupted by the Ring. He also obtained the Ring in an act of violence (technically a murder), deepening his vulnerability.
As a righteous king with the blood of Númenor in his veins though, Isildur had the wisdom to see that he was unable to control the Ring, and was on his way to Elrond seeking counsel and protection for the Ring when it abandoned him, leading to his death. Although far from incorruptible, Isildur ranks higher than those who completely surrendered to its will immediately.
4
Samwise Gamgee
Frodo’s loyal companion resisted the Ring’s temptation for two days.
Tolkien himself has said that Samwise Gamgee was the “chief hero” of The Lord of the Rings saga in one of the many letters written in his life addressing various elements of his magnum opus. As the principle representative of loyalty, sacrifice, and simple love, Sam is just as integral to the destruction of the Ring as Frodo is, and he proves it in the short time he bears the Ring himself.
Despite never wearing the Ring, it attempts to sway his mind by granting him visions of himself as a warrior hero and master gardener who would defeat all evil and return Mordor to a land of green and plenty. With zero desire for power and loyalty to his companion in his heart, Sam is able to dismiss the visions as Sauron’s treachery and carry on. This proves that he was particularly resistant to the Ring, although he was only ever given the chance to prove it in a single instance as opposed to over a span of months or years.
3
Bilbo Baggins
The Ring prolonged the life of the adventurous Hobbit for 60 years.
The accidental nature of Biblo’s acquisition of the Ring set him on a better path than others when it came to resisting its evil. He also proved in short order that he was on firmer moral ground by showing Gollum mercy as opposed to killing him when he had the opportunity to. As a Hobbit who only desired comfort, safety, and the quiet life of The Shire, there was no malice or lust for power in his soul for the Ring to corrupt. Even in his limited use of the Ring, Bilbo displayed no ill will or desire for cruelty, using it for practical or ultimately harmless reasons like escaping goblins or disappearing at his birthday party.
Bilbo was able to freely give up the Ring on his own, although the pull to retain it himself was still there, which is the greatest evidence of his ability to resist it. The scene of him attempting to reclaim it in the movie version of The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, doesn’t occur in the book, and while it makes for a memorable moment, the fact that Bilbo immediately regrets his actions and apologizes for inflicting the burden on Frodo ensures that Peter Jackson’s vision stayed true to Tolkien’s original intentions for Bilbo.
2
Frodo Baggins
In Tolkien’s novels, Frodo has the Ring for 17 years before his journey to Mordor.
The method of acquisition carries weight in how corruptible a ring-bearer might be, and that’s perhaps the most important element for Frodo Baggins. Like Bilbo, Sam, or any other Hobbit, he has no desire to conquer others, so there is little in his soul to corrupt in the first place. But the key difference between Frodo and Bilbo is that, while Bilbo discovered the Ring by accident, Frodo volunteered to carry it himself—not out of desire or pride, but out of love and duty to his friends and The Shire itself.
Frodo’s humility and selflessness is what allows him to resist the Ring for so long, living in close proximity to it for 17 years before wearing it around his neck on his months-long journey to Mordor to destroy it. While Frodo was ultimately unable to drop it into the flames of Mount Doom when the time came, that is not due to any moral failing on his part. Rather, the will of the Ring was all but unstoppable at the moment it was so close to its own destruction, and therefore the destruction of the spirit of Sauron. With all that evil pressing against him, along with the 18 months of physical and psychological torment it inflicted upon him, Frodo simply reached a breaking point.
1
Tom Bombadil
The mysterious ancient entity wears the One Ring with no effect.
Peter Jackson’s movies omit the mysterious character of Tom Bombadil entirely, but it’s important to note that Frodo and his fellow Hobbits find themselves in his house early on in their journey to Rivendell in The Fellowship of the Ring. Not fully grasping the gravity of what he carried yet, Frodo hands the Ring over to Tom for examination, and to Frodo’s shock, Tom puts the Ring on and doesn’t turn invisible or show any outward effects. He then tosses it in the air and executes a sleight of hand trick, further underscoring how little it actually means to him.
As an ancient, primordial entity who claims to have existed in the time before the creation of the Valar, Tom Bombadil essentially exists outside the natural law, or at the very least isn’t constrained to the rules that affect all others. He is even briefly discussed as an option to bring the Ring to Mordor for destruction at the Council of Elrond, but is dismissed due to the belief that it would be so trivial to him, he might lose it. Tom Bombadil is truly incorruptible when it comes to the evil of Sauron and the One Ring, but cares so little for anything outside of his own circle of influence in nature that he winds up inconsequential in the overarching narrative of Middle-earth.
This story originally appeared on Movieweb
