Youth mental health has been in the dumps and getting worse for years, but new data suggests there might be a glimmer of hope amidst the darkness.
Youth mental health has been improving on a variety of metrics, according to a new report from the Institute for Family Studies. After a peak of suffering around the pandemic in 2021, self-reported rates of depression and suicidal ideation seem to have returned to a pre-pandemic baseline.
“Thankfully, in the last few years, we’ve seen things come back toward where they were around 2010,” Jonathan Rothwell, author of the report and principal economist at Gallup, told The Post. “It seems like things have kind of gone back to the mean of where they were, rather than being at this really elevated level. And so that’s reassuring.”
It’s finally a positive indicator, but we shouldn’t celebrate too quickly. The fact that kids are doing better now than they were in the immediate wake of a global pandemic isn’t exactly a victory.
Rothwell analyzed biennial data from the CDC’s survey of high school students and found that mental health indicators have been continuously and gradually improving since 2021.
The survey asks kids if they’ve felt so sad for at least two weeks that they stopped doing their usual activities, a proxy for depressive symptoms. Amazingly, at the 2021 peak, a full 42% of high school students had. Today, that’s improved to a concerning but still better 33%, which Rothwell considers “much closer to the long-run average.”
The percentage of high school students who experienced suicidal ideation dropped from 22.2% in 2021 to 14.5% in 2025, the most recent available data. And the portion of kids who reported actual suicide attempts fell from 10.2% to 6.4% over the same time period.
Those numbers should be taken with a grain of salt; they’re self-reported, and the same survey found that just 2.9% of kids said their suicide attempt required any kind of treatment from a medical professional. Still staggering numbers, but useful context.
It comes as no surprise that 2021 seems to be the peak of teen misery. Kids were terrified by a global pandemic, pulled out of school, and separated from their friends. We should expect that they’re doing better since.
Rothwell agrees that the pandemic was a perfect combination of exactly the circumstances that would degrade the mental health of young people: “social distancing, school closures, sports leagues shutting down, religious services closing, and doing everything remotely.”
He added, “Adults also seem to have suffered during the pandemic in terms of depression and anxiety, so it would be natural to expect to see that in children, too.”
Thank god that’s behind us. But Jean Twenge, a psychologist and expert in generational changes, warned against celebrating some sort of return to normal. She told The Post that “nearly all indicators are down to the rates of 2019, not to the rates of 2011.”
“Teen mental health [looks better] than it was in the pandemic, but rates of adolescent depression, self-harm, and suicide are still much higher than they were 15 years ago,” she wrote on her Substack, Generation Tech. “We should continue to do everything we can to bring these rates of suffering down.”
Corey Keyes, an Emory University sociologist, was even more explicit: “The problem is that we accommodate a new normal. People will [see this data] and think things are better, but really, truly? In a perverse way, yes, but that’s because things got so bad.”
He’s long argued that our mental health crisis is the product of languishing, resulting from the loss of things that help people flourish.
“We as a nation seem obsessed with monitoring the presence of bad things and bad feelings and emotions,” he said. “We never bother to [acknowledge] that what precedes [these] negative things is the loss of good things: having no purpose, having little confidence, having no warm and close relationships, having no connection to a community.”
He added, “We are lazy when it comes to mental health — we would rather let people break down than help them when they are losing their well-being.”
I think there’s some real truth to that. Our approach to youth mental health is profoundly reactive. But our intuition should have told us that we’ve been setting kids up for the misery they now feel.
Over the past several decades, we’ve increasingly helicopter-parented children, preventing them from going out and playing and having freedom and unstructured time. We increasingly taught them the habits of community engagement, whether that means socializing with neighbors or going to church.
We gave them electronic devices that sucked up their time and attention and changed the way they communicated with one another. Then, after all that, we ripped them from school during the pandemic and refused to return them to their friends and education, even after international data suggested their health risk from Covid-19 was minimal.
A victory for youth mental health isn’t just about a few percentage points. It requires our culture to reconstruct the pillars of a healthy, fulfilling human life that we’ve gradually decided to tear down and rob young people of.
This story originally appeared on NYPost
