Wednesday, November 18, 2026

 
HomeOPINIONNYC turns its back on abused kids — and ties judges' hands...

NYC turns its back on abused kids — and ties judges’ hands tighter

When deciding whether it’s safe to leave a child with a parent who has abused or neglected them, New York City’s Family Courts want less information, not more.

That’s the only reasonable conclusion from the court’s announcement this month that it will restrict its judges’ ability to require on-site drug tests for parents as part of court proceedings.

The move stems from a federal lawsuit filed last year by the Bronx Defenders in the Southern District of New York.

For decades, Family Court judges could initiate courthouse drug tests at their discretion — but the policy was put on hold during the pandemic.

When ranking judges moved last fall to reinstate the rule, the leftist advocates filed suit, arguing that the tests gave judges “unchecked discretion” and that the requests made of parents were “biased and harassing.”

Even though parents had the right to refuse the tests, the lawsuit suggested that they felt compelled to comply for fear of losing custody of their children.

The lawyers also objected to the “indignity” parents experienced by having to submit to the test in the presence of a court officer.

In response, New York City Family Court simply caved.

Now, drug testing can be requested only by lawyers for the child or the parent, not by the judge.

Other changes: The judge can’t announce drug-test results in front of uninvolved observers, and any tests must be performed by a staffer who shares the parent’s “gender identity.”

Fine. Whatever.

But hamstringing a judge’s ability to figure out if a parent who wants to bring a kid home is sober?

Come on.

The truth is that substance abuse is a significant factor in child welfare cases, affecting up to 90% of the families in the system.

And the risks of parental drug use, particularly by parents of young children, are high.

According to the database Lives Cut Short, a joint project of the American Enterprise Institute and UNC Chapel Hill, a parent’s or caregiver’s substance use was involved in the cases of 171 children who died of abuse or neglect in New York state since 2022, when judges’ drug-test abilities were curtailed.

And those are just the ones we know about.

Take the case of 11-month-old Jazeli Mirabal of The Bronx, who drowned in 2024 when her mother left her in a water-filled bathtub while she went shopping and picked up her other children.

When asked why, the mom said the baby “looked comfortable” and she didn’t “want to bother her.”

Perhaps not surprisingly, the woman had a long history of drug abuse: One of her other children was born substance-exposed, and an Administration for Children’s Services investigation had previously found evidence of marijuana, PCP and cocaine in the mother’s system.

So what happens when judges cannot request a test at the courthouse?

Ronald Richter, who served as a family court judge in Queens before becoming the head of the ACS under Mayor Mike Bloomberg, says he faced this situation regularly in his courtroom.

“As a judge, you don’t want to remove the child,” he told me.

“So I would say to the parent’s lawyer, ‘Will your client consent to take a test in the courthouse?’” — as a way to determine, in the initial phases of a case, whether it’s safe to send a child home with that parent.  

Particularly in cases of young children who can’t take care of themselves, Richter says, judges need to be sure they’re releasing kids only to adults who are sober enough to care for them.

In many of these situations, he said, a clean drug test can actually help a parent regain custody.

To Richter, ordering a drug test is no different from a Family Court judge’s ability “to order a short mental health evaluation” of a parent, “to determine whether they are a danger to themselves or others.”

We don’t know whether a courthouse drug test could have prevented Jazeli’s tragic death.

Was there an occasion when ACS could have removed her and a judge could have asked for evidence of her mother’s sobriety?

Very likely: Jazeli’s mother had an extensive history of ACS involvement, including for allegations of drug use while caregiving, from 2022 to 2024.

As Richter says, these hearings are a “fact-finding process.”

The only question is why New York’s Family Courts seem determined to remain ignorant of the facts.

Naomi Schaefer Riley is a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.



This story originally appeared on NYPost

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Recent Comments